Lawsuits Against Family Guy
Due to its below-the-belt and crass humor style, Family Guy didn’t get away with some lawsuits filed within the year of 2007.
Famous comedian Carol Burnett filed a lawsuit of copyright infringement against 20th century Fox on March 2007. She claims that her character as a cleaning chairwoman was used on the television show without her consent. She also said that Fox has abused her publicity rights. A $6 million worth of damages was demanded by Burnett. But on 4th of June of the same year, United States District Judge Dean Pregerson dumped the lawsuit because the spoof was protected by the First Amendment, using Hustler versus Falwell case as an example.
Another copyright infringement lawsuit was filed on the 3rd of October 2007 by Bourne Co. Music Publishers. The lawsuit was addressed against Seth MacFarlane, 20th Century Fox Film Corp., Cartoon Network, Fox Broadcasting Co. and composer Walter Murphy. Bourne Co. Music Publishers claims that the show used the song “When You Wished upon a Star” to a imitation song that has a title of “I Need a Jew” which was used in the “When You Wish upon a Weinstein” episode. The Bourne Co., whom has the exclusive rights for the said original song claims that the “I Need a Jew” song was obviously an imitation of their music only with anti-Jewish lyrics. The lawsuit demands unspecified damages and the cessation of the distribution of the program Family Guy. This case is not be protected by the First Amendment because “I Need a Jew” really used the copyrighted song without giving credit to the owner.
The third copyright infringement lawsuit was filed by the actor/comedian Art Metrano on December 2007. The lawsuit is about a specific scene in “Stewie Griffin: The Untold Story”. The scene shows Jesus using Metrano’s original “magic” act with ridiculous imitation of magical hand motions while humming the familiar tune “Fine and Dandy.” The actor pleads that the performance is covered under terms of the U.S. Copyright Act of 1976.
